Denaturalization of the public function by the Superior Courts of Justice: incompatible health as grounds for vacancy of the public function. Critical analysis of the sentence handed down in case 58.355-2021 of the Hon. Supreme Court of Chile
Keywords:
Public function, serviceability and regularity of the Public Administration, incompatible healthAbstract
For some time now, the Hon. Supreme Court has introduced an individualistic interpretation of the public function in its rulings on vacancy due to incompatible health, distorting it and losing sight of the foundation of the regulatory differences that exist between public and private employment. In these lines I will analyze the reason of the different regulation, how that foundation has been rescued both by the Constitutional Court and by the Comptroller General of the Republic, and the problem that it represents, for the validity of the Principles of Serviceability and Regularity of the Public Administration, the denaturalization of the public function, regarding the recent jurisprudence of the highest court concerning the cause of vacancy called “incompatible health with the performance of the position”.References
Arancibia Mattar, J. (2017). La Relación jurídica público-privada: íter conceptual, atributos y criterios. En E. Soto (ed.). El Derecho Administrativo y la protección de las personas. Libro homenaje a 30 años de docencia del profesor Ramiro Mendoza en la UC. Santiago: Ediciones UC.
Bermúdez Soto, J. (2014). Derecho Administrativo General (3.° ed.). Santiago: Editorial Thomson Reuters.
Gómez González, R. (2021). Discrecionalidad y potestad administrativa sancionadora. Límites y mecanismos de control. Valencia: Tirant Lo Blanch.
Huepe, F., Morales, B., y Santibáñez, F. (2019). Vicios del acto administrativo. Santiago: Ediciones DER Ltda.
Ojeda, B. (2001). El régimen municipal chileno. Santiago: LOM Ediciones.
Parejo, L. (2018). Lecciones de Derecho Administrativo (9.° ed.). Valencia: Tirant Lo Blanch.
Peña, C. (16 de octubre de 2019). La vulgarización del derecho. Nuevo poder. http://www.nuevopoder.cl/la-vulgarizaciondel-derecho/
Valdivia, J.M. (2017). Reflexiones sobre las acciones en Derecho Administrativo. En A. Schopf y J. Marín (Ed). Lo Público y lo Privado en el Derecho. Estudios en homenaje al Profesor Enrique Barros Bourie. Santiago: Thomson Reuters.
Valdivia, J.M. (2018). Manual de Derecho Administrativo. Valencia: Tirant Lo Blanch.
Vergara, A. (2018). Derecho Administrativo: Identidad y Transformaciones. Santiago: Ediciones UC.
Zúñiga, F. (2013). Tratado jurisprudencial de Derecho Administrativo. Bases Constitucionales de la Administración del Estado. Tomo I. Santiago: Thomson Reuters.
Downloads
Published
Issue
Section
License
The authors of the articles published in the Digital Legal Magazine UANDES agree on the terms of publication, distribution, preservation, and content use contemplated in the licence:
This work is under a license of Creative Commons Atribución 4.0 Internacional.
The agreement to these terms will be done as follows: together with its article proposal, the authors should send a letter transferring their rights, license and novelty to the magazine, according to the model provided in the Announcement section of the website.
